“Lo que el Profeta ha prohibido, también lo ha prohibido Alá.”
“Dear brother/sister,”
“The translation of the hadith is as follows:”
“Another hadith with the same content was narrated by Mikdâm b. Ma’dîkerib (may Allah be pleased with him).”
“En estas aleyas se puede ver claramente el poder del Profeta (que la paz y las bendiciones sean con él) para prohibir.”
“After being mentioned in the second verse, it is also clearly mentioned what the Messenger has prohibited. Therefore, it would be incorrect to limit both things only to the prohibitions of Allah. Since the prohibition of Allah is mentioned in the verses, the prohibition of the Messenger must be separated from it. However, the prohibition of the Messenger is also by the permission of Allah.”
“Saludos y oraciones…””Preguntas sobre el Islam”
Yorumlar
‘Este tema ha sido movido con sus respuestas y comentarios, haz clic para leer…’
“They are saying that our prophet has the power to prohibit things. They are also supporting this with verses from the Quran. However, there is a hadith in which our prophet was warned by God for prohibiting things that God had not prohibited, after saying ‘Let garlic be prohibited for me’. I don’t know how much truth there is in this hadith. But if it is true, can we not say that the prophet does not have the power to prohibit things?” “Están diciendo que nuestro profeta tiene el poder de prohibir cosas. También están respaldando esto con versículos del Corán. Sin embargo, hay un hadiz en el que nuestro profeta fue advertido por Dios por prohibir cosas que Dios no había prohibido, después de decir ‘Que el ajo sea prohibido para mí’. No sé cuánta verdad hay en este hadiz. Pero si es verdad, ¿no podemos decir que el profeta no tiene el poder de prohibir cosas?”